Make this page my home page
  1. Drag the home icon in this panel and drop it onto the "house icon" in the tool bar for the browser

  2. Select "Yes" from the popup window and you're done!

Print Comment RSS

NTSB: SF plane crash victim was run over by two fire trucks

The teen was hit by a vehicle spraying foam and later by another rig leaving for more water

San Francisco Chronicle

SAN FRANCISCO, Calif. — A teenage survivor of the Asiana Airlines crash at San Francisco International Airport was run over by not one but two Fire Department rigs after firefighters mistakenly concluded she was dead without checking her vital signs, according to findings of a federal investigation released Wednesday.

The Fire Department had already admitted that one foam-spraying rig ran over 16-year-old Ye Meng Yuan of China as it took part in firefighting efforts after the July 6 crash.

But documents released Wednesday show that a second rig also ran over Ye. That rig's spotter had seen the girl on the ground and directed the driver around her as she lay near the burning Boeing 777's left wing.

The spotter then went to help at the crash site. Fourteen minutes later, that rig was the first to strike the girl, who by then was covered with flame-retardant foam, according to summaries of firefighter interviews released by the National Transportation Safety Board.

Second rig

Several minutes later, another rig ran over Ye as the driver left to refill her vehicle with water.

The San Mateo County coroner has concluded that Ye was alive before she was struck. However, she appeared to be dead to firefighters who saw her in the first minutes after the crash, the federal documents show.

Roger Phillips, a firefighter based at the airport, was the first to spot Ye as he was riding in a rig called Rescue 10. He told investigators that he got out of his rig and walked 15 feet to where she lay.

"She looked to be dead 'by appearance,' but he did not check her vitals," according to the safety board's summary of its interview with Phillips. "He thought it was a mannequin because her face looked like wax. Her eyes were rolled back and her face 'looked like a grimace.'

"The body looked like a CPR dummy they used for training," Phillips said, according to the summary.

Phillips said he notified Rescue 10's driver, Jimmy Yee, about the girl and directed him around her, then told fire Lt. Christine Emmons about the find.

According to Phillips' account to the safety board, "She replied, 'Yes, yes, OK, OK. We've gotta get a line inside,' " referring to the need to get a hose into the burning craft as part of an effort to rescue victims.

Yee told fire officials that Phillips had identified an obstacle for him to avoid. "As I drove by, being careful not to run over what I thought was debris, I saw that it was a deceased victim," Yee said.

Emmons told federal investigators that she had seen the girl and "immediately categorized it as a casualty," the safety board said.

'Our first casualty'

The girl "was not making any sounds and was not moving," Emmons told investigators. "She made a 'three-second' visual assessment and thought, 'That's our first casualty,' and considered her as 'DOA' - but she also wanted to make sure she was not rolled over by a vehicle."

Rescue 10 maneuvered around the girl at 11:36 a.m., about nine minutes after Asiana Flight 214 had crashed. However, 14 minutes after it drove around her, Rescue 10 moved near the left wing and ran over Ye, the safety board's report says, citing surveillance-camera footage taken aboard the rig. By that point, the girl was covered in foam.

Then, at 12:01 p.m., a second rig, known as Rescue 37, also ran over Ye's foam-obscured body as the driver, Elyse Duckett, went to refill the vehicle with water, the report says. That is the rig visible in footage of the scene recorded by the helmet camera of a commanding officer, Battalion Chief Mark Johnson.

Another firefighter pointed out Ye's body to Johnson a short time after Rescue 37 hit her, according to the helmet-camera footage, which was reviewed by The Chronicle. It was apparently the first time any fire supervisor at the scene had been alerted to Ye's presence.

Duckett's July 9 statement to Fire Department investigators contains no indication that she knew she had run over anyone.

There is no summary of any interview with Johnson in the documents the federal safety board released.

It is unclear how Ye, who was sitting toward the back of the plane, ended up on the ground by the left wing. However, Deborah Hersman, chairwoman of the federal safety board, said interviews with other passengers indicated that Ye hadn't been wearing her seat belt and may have been thrown from the plane.

Under firefighting protocols, Ye's body should have been marked and protected as crash evidence even if she was dead before being run over. However, none of the firefighters who reported seeing her and concluding she was dead said they told Fire Department superiors of their find.

Firefighters weren't the only ones who thought Ye was dead. Henry Choy, a safety officer who works for the airport, told federal investigators that he had seen the girl before she was run over and that "he did not realize it was a real person," the safety board said.

"There was no blood around the body and there was no movement," the summary of Choy's interview said. "It looked more like a 'big doll.' "

Assistant chief testifies

In an interview with safety board investigators, Assistant Deputy Fire Chief Dale Carnes said firefighters had thought Ye "was obviously deceased."

He testified before the board Wednesday and said, "It is not a matter of us being careless or callous - it was the fact that we were dealing with a complex and dynamic environment and we were focused on saving as many lives as possible."

San Mateo County Coroner Robert Foucrault, told that firefighters hadn't checked Ye's vital signs, said in an interview with The Chronicle, "That's not how you pronounce somebody dead."

"There has never been any documentation to support that she was obviously dead or any protocol to make that determination," Foucrault said. "There's overwhelming scientific evidence to prove that she was alive when she was struck."

Copyright 2013 San Francisco Chronicle

McClatchy-Tribune News Service

All Rights Reserved

The comments below are member-generated and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of or its staff. If you cannot see comments, try disabling privacy and ad blocking plugins in your browser. All comments must comply with our Member Commenting Policy.
Friday, December 13, 2013 1:20:27 PM Come on Asst. Chief Carnes, don't defend that pathetic administration, tell the truth, the SFFD was and is poorly trained and their actions show it, they are an embarrassment to the profession. Fire fighters go to the airport to hide...obviously it came back to bite them on the ass!!!!!!! They without a doubt f#$ked up!!!!! How could they even describe what they did in that way, it shows their stupidity , it shows their absolute lack of training and knowledge of there responsibility in their role as rescuers using a technique called start triage. This fire department is so remiss at taking responsibility and learning lessons, it truly makes one wonder how much longer it can go on...I really love a quote I heard about how the fish rots from the head down... from the rotting top to the fish as a whole. Is money the only thing with value??? This city is not poor and it is obvious they need to shell out a little more of their funds on training the people they hang the expectation on to manage choatic events, from major fires to plane crashes. It's called, in the professional world "deliberate indifference" You know the potential for chaos to happen, but due to very poor judgement allow fire fighters to be irresponsible as a collective team. shame shame shame!!!!!!!!!!!!!! When you live in the world of denial and you don't allow the truth to surface...and if the truth is hidden behind lies how is a corrective course of action ever going to manifest. We will forever be on the wrong train on the wrong track!!!! where's the leadership needed to reroute the train??????
Dave Bishop Dave Bishop Thursday, December 19, 2013 10:59:43 AM OK mic, don't start throwing rocks because SFFD has a Woman Chief Officer ! This is a tragic accident ! No more, no less. A body obscured by foam . . . . yes the FF's had the responsibility to pass it up the chain so not to contaminate the "crime scene" until proven otherwise, HOWEVER, that likely dates back thru a few other Chief Officer administrations ! Just like the drunk tiller driver who struck a motorcycle while responding . . . . .no doubt SFFD needs to be held to account for PAST as well as current failures that date back years before the current Chief took her oath. But lets give the new Chief some credit for addressing these issues as she goes, rather than ignore them as other Chiefs probably have because the union probably threatened "blue flu" if corrective action was taken by other Chiefs.

FireRescue1 Offers

Connect with FireRescue1

Mobile Apps Facebook Twitter Google+