5 reasons firefighters need lightweight PPE
Wearing lighter gear that provides more ease of movement can go a long way in reducing the risk of heat stress for firefighters
Sponsored by TenCate Protective Fabrics
By Robert Avsec for FireRescue1 BrandFocus
Your structural firefighting protective ensemble, aka your turnout gear or PPE, is a marvel of design engineering that meets its primary objective – protecting you from the thermal hazards of structural firefighting – extremely well. But are you aware of the risk to your health and well-being that also comes with working in your PPE?
Here are five reasons firefighters need lightweight PPE:
1. HEAT STRESS CAN KILL YOU
Denise Smith, Ph.D., is the director of the First Responder Health and Safety Laboratory and a subject matter expert regarding heat stress and its effect on firefighter health and safety. In that role, she served as the principal investigator for the Science Medicine and Research & Technology for Emergency Responders (SMARTER) project, a study supported by the DHS/FEMA Grant Directorate for the Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program with a Fire Prevention and Safety Grant.
Smith and her research team published the project’s key findings in 2015 with a paper titled, Effect of Heat Stress and Dehydration on Cardiovascular Function, in which they wrote:
Firefighters are exposed to numerous life-threatening dangers, including high temperatures, flames, smoke, hazardous chemicals, and unstable structures. Despite these dangers, the physiological strain, specifically cardiovascular strain, associated with firefighting poses the greatest threat to the life and health of a firefighter .
Smith and her team found that working in their full structural ensemble and SCBA, firefighters put their bodies at risk of developing hyperthermia and dehydration, factors they dubbed the “Terrible Twins.”
The development of the “Terrible Twins” leads to an increased strain on your cardiovascular system that can manifest itself in two ways:
- A sudden cardiac event, such as heart attack or stroke.
- Early onset of fatigue, causing slower work on your part, which can contribute to increased fire growth (because you’re working slower), which can in turn contribute to a greater risk of slips or falls as you struggle to get the job done.
2. HEAVIER PPE INCREASES THE RISK OF HEAT STRESS
A firefighter is at risk of developing the “Terrible Twins” from the moment they don their turnout gear and SCBA. The body heat being generated by the firefighter working in an ensemble:
- Makes it difficult for the body to cool through evaporation of perspiration.
- Decreases the firefighter’s mobility so that they have to work harder (which exacerbates the generation of body heat that the body cannot release).
When you see a red-faced firefighter just after they’ve removed their SCBA facepiece and helmet and hood, you’re seeing a body that’s doing its best to shed that built-up heat. It’s doing so by pumping more blood to the vessels of the head and neck in an attempt to release heat through radiation (the hotter head and neck exposed to a cooler ambient air temperature) and getting as much evaporation as possible from the only skin that’s exposed to outside air.
3. POTENTIAL FOR STEAM BURNS
The increase in body heat being generated – and the body’s inability to adequately cool the firefighter through evaporation of perspiration – also presents another potential hazard to the firefighter: steam burns.
In a research study initiated in 2015, the National Institute for Testing and Standards began looking at this risk. In the potential steam burn mechanism NIST is exploring, water vapor accumulates in a burning room, penetrates the firefighters’ protective clothing and collects in the layer of air between clothing and skin. Water vapor from human perspiration also increases the humidity in this air layer .
Your structural ensemble has three key layers of fabric:
- An outer shell (e.g., Kevlar, Nomex, PBI) that’s your first line of defense against flames and heat.
- A middle layer (moisture barrier) that repels liquids on one side but allows perspiration to evaporate
- Closest to your skin, a quilted thermal liner for insulation.
That middle layer – the moisture barrier – is a two-way street, in that vapor (water/sweat in its gaseous form) can penetrate the barrier. During interior structural firefighting, there’s plenty of water vapor in the space because of the water you’re applying to the fire. Water vapor is also filling the space as a byproduct of combustion.
All that water vapor in the air means a greater chance that it will find its way into relatively dry places, such as the air spaces between those three layers of PPE. Within those air spaces, there is a threshold moisture content, the dew point, at which the air space can no longer absorb moisture.
When these interior air spaces within reach their dew points, any additional moisture entering those spaces begins condensing into liquid droplets on the skin. This transition from vapor to liquid releases heat and raises the temperature of the skin – not a desirable effect, given that the body is trying to shed excess heat.
While the research into this phenomenon continues, we know that irreversible skin damage can occur within minutes at around 118 degrees F (48 degrees C). The theory being explored by NIST is that when the moisture level in the air layer between your skin and the moisture barrier gets high enough, steam burns might become possible.
4. LIGHTER STRUCTURAL PPE IS THE KEY
The manufacturers of firefighting PPE work diligently to develop garments that provide a safe, effective and efficient solution to the problem of excess heat buildup while still maintaining the required protection from the external heat presented by structural firefighting.
One aspect of that pursuit is designing PPE that’s lighter and that provides better flexibility and freedom of movement so that your PPE is working with you and not against you. The heavier and more constraining your PPE is, the harder you must work, risking the development of the “Terrible Twins.”
If your fire department is looking to replace or upgrade its structural firefighting PPE, consider newer, lighter weight options. The fabric engineers at TenCate Protective Fabrics have developed PBI Peak 5, an outer shell fabric that’s lighter (5.6 ounces per square yard), with the highest percentage of PBI fiber currently available in the market. Using the company’s unique ENFORCE Technology, they’ve combined the thermal protection of PBI with the time-tested strength of Kevlar to create an outer shell that can meet the protection demands of 21st-century firefighting.
These advances mean you can now get an outer shell that provides outstanding thermal protection and is 20 percent stronger than comparable outer shell fabrics so it can withstand the abrasion, wear and tear hazards that firefighters face every day. The lighter weight also means it’s less stiff, more comfortable right out of the box and provides added range of motion.
5. LOOK BEYOND STRUCTURAL PPE
Having the right gear for the job can make your job safer and easier, particularly when it comes to reducing the risk of heat stress. For many fire departments, responses to working structure fires where structural PPE is required account for a only small percentage of their total responses. Those same fire departments are responding to a far greater number of calls where their structural firefighting PPE is working against them instead of for them.
TenCate Protective Fabrics has created a new fabric to help address this problem and provide fire departments with PPE options beyond the structural firefighting ensemble. Agility Tactical is lightweight (just 5 ounces per square yard), durable and compliant with NFPA 1951, NFPA 1977 and NFPA 1999. That tri-certification now gives PPE manufacturers a lighter weight fabric they can use to make multi-functional PPE for firefighters to wear in a variety of non-structural firefighter tasks, including rescue missions and training.
“Now you can have a garment that’s both multifunctional and highly efficient in those tasks like vehicle extrication, wildland urban interface and delivery of EMS,” said Jeff Sedivec, a retired firefighter (Santa Ana, Calif.) and now end user/dealer market manager for TenCate Protective Fabrics. “And because those garments won’t have the bulky thermal protection layer you have in structural PPE, the firefighter wearing it has a lower risk of heat stress and the physical problems that heat stress can bring on.”
Wearing lighter PPE that provides more ease of movement can go a long way in reducing the risk of heat stress for firefighters. Fire departments can also reduce that risk by providing their personnel with lighter PPE options that more closely match the hazards they encounter while doing their jobs.
For more information, visit TenCate Protective Fabrics.
1. Smith, D. L., DeBlois, J. P., Haller, J. M., Lefferts, W. K., & Fehling, P. C. (2015). Effect of Heat Stress and Dehydration on Cardiovascular Function. Retrieved from skidmore.edu: https://www.skidmore.edu/responder/documents/smith-dhsS10-fs-report.pdf
2. NIST. (2015, April 27). Why Firefighters Get Steam Burns: Exploratory Study Underway. Retrieved from National Institute of Standards and Technology: https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2015/04/why-firefighters-get-steam-burns-exploratory-study-underway