Part of the job
However a department decides to address the issue of search operations, it will be required to justify its decision
Editor’s Note:Editor's note: With a city defending its response to a fatal N.Y. fire, our Editorial Advisor Chief Adam K. Thiel looks at the wider issues involved.
Perhaps like many of you, I've been thinking a lot lately about when we should, and should not, commit firefighters to perform searches in unoccupied, abandoned, and vacant buildings. (I assign these categories somewhat arbitrarily, since there doesn't seem to be a generally agreed-upon fire service definition.)
On the one hand, we know that many firefighters have been killed and injured over the years in abandoned buildings. I'll never forget standing outside the Worcester Centrum (now the DCU Center) at the December 1999 funeral for our six brothers who died in the vacant Worcester Cold Storage Warehouse.
Since then, a number of Worcester firefighters have traveled the country sharing their story. (If you've never attended one of their seminars, GO! It's vital information.) The December 2010 deaths of our two brothers in Chicago reinforces the hazardous nature of fighting fires in such buildings.
On the other hand, I was taught — as were many of us — that we can never assume a building is vacant until/unless we search it. The recent fire in New Orleans that claimed eight lives in an abandoned warehouse supports a concern for people who might be taking shelter inside structures that are not intended for human habitation.
While a potentially vacant apartment in an otherwise occupied building is a slightly different scenario from the above incidents, this latest story from Schenectady, N.Y., suggests that however a fire department decides to address the issue, it will be subjected to intense public scrutiny and required to justify its decision.
It's all too easy for people to Monday morning quarterback after a civilian or firefighter is killed or injured in a fire. Those of us who've made go or no-go decisions in front of burning buildings understand how difficult it can be with limited, incomplete, and often incorrect information.
Whatever you decide, rest assured that you will be questioned, second-guessed, and held accountable for the results; it's part of the job.
Recommended for you
Join the discussion
The comments below are member-generated and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of FireRescue1.com or its staff. If you cannot see comments, try disabling privacy and ad blocking plugins in your browser. All comments must comply with our Member Commenting Policy.