By Battalion Chief Grant Tinker
When we ask about what motivates firefighters to pursue training on their own time, the answers seem obvious. It’s about getting better, staying sharp, and progressing in the job.
But after looking at this year’s What Firefighters Want survey data, I think there’s something deeper behind it. Here’s the snapshot of responses. Respondents could select their top three motivations.
| READ MORE: What Firefighters Want in 2026: Time to Train
Firefighters are not just motivated by improvement; they are motivated by a desire to not fail. And even more than that, they are motivated by a desire not to let others down.
The academy
From day one in the fire academy, we are trained and evaluated against clear, structured standards. Whether it’s NFPA guidelines, department expectations or skill sheets, everything is broken down into specific check-box steps. Competency is measured in a very black-and-white format where you either meet the standard or you don’t.
To throw a ladder, advance a hoseline or perform a search, there is a defined sequence and a clear path from point A to point B. That structure creates clarity and consistency, but it also creates conditioning. We learn early on that performance is measured, judged and ultimately categorized as a success or a failure — no middle ground.
Day one
The shift happens the moment the academy ends. We are no longer evaluated in that same structured, objective way. Instead, we learn through experience, observation and informal feedback. Much of our development comes from on-the-job training, where learning is shaped by real incidents rather than controlled environments.
In many cases, the feedback we receive focuses more on what went wrong than what went right. At the same time, the environment becomes far less predictable. No two structure fires are the same, and no two incidents unfold in exactly the same way. The clear checklists we relied on early in our careers begin to fade, replaced by judgment, adaptability and decision-making in the moment.
But while the structure changes, the expectation for performance does not.
Fear of failure
No matter what’s happening in our real-world work, the early pass/fail conditioning stays with us. Over time, firefighters develop an internal pressure to perform without error. There is a constant awareness of the stakes, and with that comes a quiet but powerful drive to avoid mistakes. More than anything, there is a desire not to be the person who lets the crew down.
This is where I believe the survey data takes on a deeper meaning. When 80% of respondents say they are motivated to improve their skills, it may not just be about growth. It may be about reducing uncertainty. When 75% cite personal interest, that interest is often tied to building confidence in an environment where outcomes are rarely predictable.
The search of the structure
I see this play out frequently in requests for more strategy and tactics training.
Firefighters are often looking for clarity. They want to understand the “right” way to approach a situation, the best decision to make under pressure, and the correct sequence of actions to follow. In many ways, they are trying to recreate the structure they had in the academy, a system where expectations are clearly defined and outcomes feel more certain.
The challenge is that in the fire service, multiple approaches can be correct. Two officers can make different decisions on the same incident, and both can be effective based on conditions, experience and perspective. However, for someone who was trained in a pass/fail environment, that level of ambiguity can be uncomfortable. The desire for a clear answer doesn’t go away just because the job becomes more complex.
Trust and responsibility
At its core, I believe firefighters pursue self-directed training because they want to be trusted. They want to be someone their crew can rely on, someone their officer can depend on and someone who contributes to the overall effectiveness of the team. That trust isn’t given automatically; it’s earned through demonstrated competence and consistent performance.
Outside training becomes the pathway to that trust. Firefighters seek out opportunities to improve through hands-on drills, conferences, certifications and independent study. They are not just checking boxes; they are building a foundation that allows them to perform when it matters most. In a profession where the consequences of failure can be significant, preparation becomes a responsibility, not just a choice.
A personal reflection
This perspective isn’t just based on data; it reflects my own experience over a 24-year career.
I rarely felt completely confident in what I was doing. There was always a sense that I needed to learn more, train more and prepare more. Not out of fear, but out of responsibility. I didn’t want to be the one who made the wrong call, and I didn’t want to let my crew down.
So, I pursued knowledge the same way many firefighters do, constantly, deliberately, and on my own time trying to close the gap between uncertainty and confidence.
What this means for the fire service
If we take this data at face value, we might conclude that firefighters are highly motivated learners, and that’s true. But if we look deeper, we begin to see a more nuanced reality. Firefighters are operating in an environment where expectations are high, outcomes are uncertain, and confidence is developed over time. That has important implications for how we train and lead.
We should ask ourselves whether we are providing enough structured feedback after the academy, whether we are reinforcing what firefighters are doing well, and whether we are helping them build confidence, not just competence. These are the areas that can shape long-term development and performance.
Final thoughts
The data tells us what firefighters are doing. But the deeper question is why. From my perspective, firefighters pursue training not just to improve, but to prepare. They are preparing not only for the technical demands of the job, but for the responsibility they carry to the people around them. And ultimately, that responsibility is what drives them forward.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Grant Tinker is a battalion chief with the Colorado Springs Fire Department, currently serving as the Training Division chief. With 24 years of fire service experience, Tinker has held numerous operational, instructional and leadership positions. He is a graduate of the National Fire Academy’s Managing Officer Program and is currently in the Executive Fire Officer program. Tinker holds Chief Fire Officer and Fire Officer designations and serves as a Commissioner with the Commission on Professional Credentialing. A passionate advocate for firefighter safety and organizational leadership, Tinker presents on normalization of deviance nationwide, emphasizing accountability, risk awareness and organizational culture.