Trending Topics

Former Baltimore paramedic sues fire department over beard policy, religious accommodation

Othmane El Omari alleges he was suspended and then fired for refusing to shave a beard required by his Muslim faith

Former Baltimore paramedic sues fire department over beard policy, religious accommodation.jpg

A Baltimore Fire Department ambulance.

Baltimore Fire Department|Facebook

By Brian Carlton, Jessica Baugh
Baltimore Sun

BALTIMORE — A former Baltimore City Fire Department paramedic says he was repeatedly suspended for refusing to shave a beard required by his Muslim faith, according to a federal lawsuit.

Othmane El Omari alleges the department denied his requests for a religious accommodation, selectively enforced its grooming policy and retaliated against him after he filed a federal discrimination complaint. He was fired in March after nearly two years with the department.

| NEW RESOURCE: An AAR checklist for incident commanders

The lawsuit, filed Nov. 4 in U.S. District Court in Maryland, accuses the city of violating federal civil rights law. It seeks El Omari’s reinstatement, unspecified monetary damages and changes to department policies governing religious accommodations.

El Omari says he spent approximately six months on suspension, much of it without pay, before his termination on March 18. His attorneys contend the department refused to conduct a respirator fit test that could have helped determine whether his beard compromised his safety equipment.

“There was no reason BCFD could not have at least attempted to accommodate our client’s religious practice,” said Aya Beydoun, a CAIR staff attorney. “He was more than willing to comply with legitimate workplace safety requirements, yet BCFD refused to explore any accommodation. Our client should never have been forced to choose between his religious beliefs and his livelihood.”

The Baltimore Fire Department did not comment on the lawsuit when contacted by The Baltimore Sun.

“At this time, because this matter is the subject of pending litigation, the Department is unable to comment on the allegations or details of the case,” according to a statement from the department.

The complaint comes as the department faces another pending religious-accommodation lawsuit. In that case, paramedic Ariel Rice alleges BCFD failed to accommodate his Sabbath and holiday observance and disciplined him after he missed shifts that conflicted with his faith.

Making a request

El Omari joined the department May 8, 2024, after working for Hart to Heart, a private emergency medical services company that contracted with Baltimore.

The following day, he requested permission to maintain a beard consistent with his religious beliefs.

According to the lawsuit, a human resources representative told him an accommodation would not be available until he completed his training at the Baltimore City Fire Academy. Fearing he would lose his job, El Omari shaved, believing the requirement was temporary.

After graduating in November 2024, he renewed his request. The department denied it, citing its grooming standards.

El Omari subsequently began growing a trimmed, goatee-style beard that he believed satisfied his religious obligations without interfering with safety equipment. He maintained the facial hair for approximately six months without incident, according to the complaint.

The department’s grooming policy generally prohibits beards and goatees but provides medical exemptions for employees with certain skin conditions. Those employees can maintain limited facial hair but are restricted to light-duty assignments rather than operational work.

The conflict escalated in May 2025 when a chief noticed El Omari’s facial hair and reported him to Chief Maurice Taylor, who ordered him to shave. El Omari complied but later regrew his beard.

On Aug. 9, Capt. Dimick warned him that he would face suspension unless he shaved, according to the complaint.

El Omari refused, citing his faith. The next day, he was suspended without pay for 48 work hours for insubordination.

During an Aug. 18 meeting with Human Resources Director Nikki Lewis, El Omari again sought an accommodation and volunteered to undergo a respirator fit test to determine whether his beard interfered with the seal of his self-contained breathing apparatus.

The department did not conduct the requested test, according to the lawsuit, and declined to consider a less restrictive alternative that would have allowed El Omari to maintain his beard while satisfying workplace safety requirements. El Omari was continuously told he must shave completely, the complaint says.

The complaint accuses Baltimore of three violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964: failure to provide reasonable religious accommodation, discriminatory treatment resulting in wrongful termination and unlawful retaliation.

El Omari has requested a jury trial.

Trending
All six residents evacuated safely from the Multnomah County house, as Oregon’s lithium-ion battery fires have climbed an average of 19% annually since 2020, with e-bikes and scooters the most common cause
The Congressional Fire Services Institute named the Virginia Beach Fire Department the 2027 Sarbanes Award winner for a program focused on firefighter health, safety and readiness
The Ottumwa Fire Department wants to add six full-time personnel to run a 24-hour ambulance, but the city faces a $500,000 budget shortfall
Gatlinburg’s Drone as First Responder program has flown about 120 missions since September, often arriving before firefighters and police officers

©2026 Baltimore Sun.
Visit baltimoresun.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Company News
Backed by Motorola Solutions Foundation and other NFFF partners, 67 recipients will receive financial assistance to pursue higher education in 2026-2027 academic year