Across emergency services — from field operations to communications centers — gallows humor has become a familiar part of the job. Often surfacing during or after difficult calls, it allows responders to comment on intense or tragic circumstances with irony, sarcasm or dark wit. For those outside the profession, this may appear inappropriate or cold. But for those within, it often emerges as a spontaneous reaction to the unspeakable.
While gallows humor has a long-standing presence in public safety culture, it is not an ideal coping strategy — nor should it be treated as a substitute for emotional processing or mental health care. Rather, it’s a tool used in the moment to relieve emotional pressure, which can have both benefits and drawbacks.
READ NEXT: On-demand webinar: Firefighter therapy — busting myths and stopping stigma
Why responders use gallows humor
In the face of trauma, stress, or overwhelming grief, people instinctively search for ways to regain a sense of control. Gallows humor provides this by reframing a situation, even briefly, in absurd or ironic terms. It can help responders remain operational in high-stress moments and diffuse tension between team members.
Studies in occupational health psychology suggest that dark humor can activate the brain’s prefrontal cortex — associated with problem-solving and emotional regulation — while dampening hyperactive emotional centers like the amygdala. This can translate to temporary relief during prolonged exposure to trauma.
In some cases, shared humor between teammates can reinforce group cohesion and foster peer support. A simple joke during a difficult shift might signal to others: “You’re not alone, and we’re still here.”
But these benefits are situational and short-term. The deeper implications of this type of humor require careful scrutiny.
When dark humor becomes a liability
While gallows humor may help some responders cope in the moment, it also carries risks — particularly when used excessively or inappropriately. One of the most significant concerns is emotional suppression. When responders rely on humor to avoid dealing with trauma, it can delay healing, inhibit vulnerability and contribute to chronic stress reactions over time.
Persistent use of dark humor may also signal burnout, compassion fatigue or unresolved trauma. Jokes that once served to lighten the mood can shift toward cynicism, detachment or even dehumanization. Over time, this can affect not only an individual’s mental health but also the culture of a team or agency.
In some settings, gallows humor has been misapplied or poorly timed — leading to public outrage, disciplinary action or erosion of trust between responders and the communities they serve. When used in public forums or on social media, dark humor can appear tone-deaf or offensive, even if the intent was personal coping.
Perhaps most importantly, humor that diminishes or mocks victims — even subtly — can reinforce emotional distancing that hinders long-term psychological resilience.
Real-world context: not celebration, but observation
During major disasters, mass casualty events or high-fatality scenes, responders often turned to humor in private settings to cope. For example, responders working long hours during natural disasters may jokingly name their tents or stations with ironic labels like “Hotel 911” or “Morgue Café.” These comments, often exchanged behind the scenes, aren’t intended for the public — they’re attempts to maintain focus and endurance under emotional strain.
However, not all humor is harmless. In some documented after-action reviews, inappropriate comments during post-incident debriefs have left team members feeling isolated or invalidated. What some see as levity, others may experience as disrespect — especially when diverse life experiences or levels of trauma exposure are not considered.
A cultural norm that requires ongoing reflection
Gallows humor persists largely because of shared experience and inherited behavior. New personnel entering emergency services often learn this humor informally, mirroring seasoned responders who use it as shorthand for coping. Over time, this creates a culture where joking through trauma can feel like the only acceptable outlet.
But without proactive cultural reflection, this norm can discourage healthy emotional expression. In some agencies, personnel who don’t find the humor helpful — or who are uncomfortable with its tone — may remain silent rather than risk being seen as “soft” or “not one of the team.”
Training programs and mental health resources now recognize this tension. The goal isn’t to ban humor, but to recognize when it’s being used as avoidance rather than connection. Agencies that normalize peer support, critical incident debriefings, and mental wellness resources help broaden the emotional toolkit beyond jokes alone.
What healthy boundaries look like
There is a difference between humor used to lighten a heavy moment — and humor used to avoid facing reality. Indicators that gallows humor may be unhealthy include:
- Jokes becoming increasingly graphic, aggressive or directed at victims
- Responders who rely on humor but avoid serious discussions about their own wellbeing
- Team dynamics where humor silences emotional honesty or criticism
- Inappropriate timing, such as joking in front of civilians, families or the media
Supervisors, peer support leads and team members should be attuned to these patterns. In many cases, humor may be the entry point for a deeper conversation: “You’ve been joking a lot lately — how are you really doing?”
Final thoughts
Gallows humor is a recognizable part of emergency response culture, but it should not be mistaken for a cure-all. At best, it offers momentary relief and camaraderie; at worst, it can mask emotional injury and discourage honest dialogue. By recognizing its place — and its limits — public safety agencies can support their members in finding more sustainable paths to resilience and recovery.
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
- The human connection crisis: Why first responders need real relationships in a digital world
- From kennel to station: Building a successful therapy dog program
- Trauma recovery for first responders: You are worth the work
- Firefighter therapy: Your questions, answered
WATCH | 10 red flag phrases that signal first responders are struggling with stress
FireRescue1 is using generative AI to create some content that is edited and fact-checked by our editors.
