Trending Topics

S.C. city calls demand to fire chiefs ‘egregious’ in LODD lawsuit

Columbia says it disagrees with the allegations in the Muller lawsuit and looks forward to a trial before “a neutral and detached jury.”

US-NEWS-COLUMBIA-RESPONDS-DEMAND-FIRE-TWO-1-CS.jpg

Columbia city officials calls a demand to fire two fire officials “egregious” in litigation over Irmo firefighter James Muller’s 2023 death.

Tracy Glantz/TNS

By Javon L. Harris
The State

COLUMBIA, S.C. — The City of Columbia is pushing back against a settlement offer in a lawsuit over the 2023 death of Irmo firefighter James Michael Muller, calling a demand to fire two city fire officials “egregious.”

“The City of Columbia does not comment on pending litigation,” the city said in a Facebook post. “However, the call for the resignation of two long-standing, dedicated public servants is egregious.”

| EARLIER: S.C. LODD settlement calls for firing of fire chief, assistant chief

The statement came after the Irmo Fire District offered to resolve claims against it by calling for Columbia Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant of Operations Anthony Holloway to be terminated. The offer, filed Nov. 16 in Richland County Common Pleas Court, also seeks about $40,296 in legal fees and costs, published apologies from the two officials and dismissal of all claims against the district, according to The State.

The city said it disagrees with the allegations made by other lawyers in the case and looks forward to representing Columbia firefighters “before a neutral and detached jury.”

Muller, 25, died after an apartment building collapsed during a May 2023 fire at the Tropical Ridge complex in Columbia. Three other Irmo firefighters trapped in the collapse survived. His wife, Emma Elizabeth Muller, sued the city and Richland County; Columbia brought Irmo Fire District into the litigation as a third-party defendant.

A National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health report cited communication failures, problems tracking firefighters and insufficient understanding of the building’s structural risks. The Irmo Fire District’s offer says it is not an admission of liability and gives the recipients 20 days to accept.

One of 13 NIOSH recommendations highlights the department’s proactive mental health response, including mandatory check-ins and peer-led crisis support
Trending
Roanoke firefighters are asking city council to vote Dec. 7 on collective bargaining, as the mayor says the city is working through details
Irmo Fire District offered to resolve claims in the James Muller death lawsuit if Columbia fires Chief Aubrey Jenkins and an assistant chief
NYPD and FDNY rescuers describe how they heard a voice and got a canine alert, then dug survivors out of the Brooklyn building collapse
After the Searsmont lumber mill explosion and OSHA story, a familiar defense is making the rounds

©2026 The State.
Visit thestate.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Company News
Backed by Motorola Solutions Foundation and other NFFF partners, 67 recipients will receive financial assistance to pursue higher education in 2026-2027 academic year