By Emma Ralls
The Saratogian
SARATOGA SPRINGS, N.Y. — As the Saratoga Springs City Council is in the midst of figuring out next year’s budget, as well as a way to right the city’s current financial situation, the mayor and commissioners are considering all solutions — one of which is potential workforce layoffs — which would include both City Hall employees and firefighters.
At Tuesday night’s meeting, the City Council noted that they had entered discussions with the Union representing SSFD in hopes of finding a solution that would prevent these layoffs. However, the Saratoga Springs Firefighter’s Local 343, the union that represents the City’s fire department, shared Thursday morning in a Facebook post that the membership “overwhelmingly rejected” the City Council’s proposal.
| NEW RESOURCE: An AAR checklist for incident commanders
In the post, the union writes that “after supposedly finding $2.5 million in just 10 days,” the City Council came to the union with a proposal, asking them to accept a reduction to a 14-member minimum, which would result in three-person engine companies and would allow the potential layoffs to be avoided.
“We stand for what is right. We stand for the safety of our firefighters, the residents who pay the taxes, and the visitors who trust us to protect them,” the fire union wrote in its post. “Three-person engine companies are an unnecessary gamble with public safety. Fewer firefighters mean fewer hands when seconds matter, more time to accomplish critical tasks and greater risk for everyone involved.
“This union has a responsibility that goes beyond protecting jobs or negotiating a contract. It is our responsibility to stand up when decisions are being made that compromise the safety of the people we serve.
“You can threaten layoffs. You can attempt to coerce this membership. You can try to make us the villains in a crisis we did not create. But you will not intimidate us into accepting an unsafe staffing model. We will not sacrifice firefighter safety. We will not sacrifice public safety. And we will not be bullied into accepting a deal that compromises either.”
The Saratogian reached out to Public Safety Commissioner Tim Coll Thursday via text, who noted that nothing had changed since he shared remarks on the matter at Tuesday night’s City Council meeting – at which he commented that this current City Council had inherited the “financial storm” they are currently facing and that they have negotiated in good faith with the union. He also said Tuesday that the plan to temporarily pause four-person crews, while the City worked to identify additional revenue sources to fund them, was specifically designed to prevent layoffs.
“I have absolutely no issue with union members thoughtfully advocating on behalf of their fellow members. That is their right, and I respect it,” Coll said Tuesday evening.
“The ball is now in the union’s court. There is an opportunity to help save these jobs, and we need to work together to make that happen. I have spoken with both fire chiefs, who are subject-matter experts and responsible for the day-to-day operations of the fire department. While this is certainly not an ideal situation, both chiefs have indicated that a temporary pause in four-person crews would still allow for “adequate” fire and EMS coverage for this city.”
During the meeting, Accounts Commissioner Jess Troisi also commented on the proposal made to the fire union – noting that lengthy conversations were had with the city’s insurance agency and that there was no risk from an insurance standpoint if the number of individuals on a truck was reduced – but also acknowledging the potential layoffs wouldn’t just affect the fire department, but City Hall employees as well; explaining how difficult of a decision it is and how the council is not considering it lightly.
“There are (potential) layoffs all through City Hall, and I personally feel that every one of those jobs is just as important. I don’t think that the public works guy or the finance guy or the accounts department positions are any less valuable than the firefighters,” Troisi said. “This is not targeting the firefighters at all.
“This is just as simple as a percentage of the layoffs…Commissioner Kiernan has been diligently working from day one to try and get our finances under control. Once she had them under control, she has been bending over backwards to keep us updated on where the reality of our finances is.”
This was a sentiment echoed by Mayor John Safford at the meeting, who noted that the council has been and is going to do everything they can to try to find alternative solutions – adding the extra stress the commissioner form of government places on the council in dealing with situations such as this.
“It’s not just the fire department, believe me, every commissioner has people they’re laying off, and this is not easy. So we’re continuing to discuss it among ourselves and lobby one another,” Safford said. “The commission form of government pits us against each other – commissioners get pitted against each other at this time, and whether that’s good or bad can be determined, if you want to look into it. But that’s what’s happening, but we are together doing what we can. We are professionals here, and we are objectively looking at the needs of the city and how to make a balanced budget.”
“We’re doing the best that we can with some very smart people working with us.”
The council has a special meeting scheduled for next Monday, Nov. 23, to further discuss the budget and other options. There will be a second special meeting on Nov. 30, at which the budget must be voted on.
Following Tuesday’s meeting, Kiernan spoke with The Saratogian about the work going into coming up with the 2027 budget and the potential outcomes that could be on the table, acknowledging that if the city forgoes these layoffs of city employees and firefighters, residents might have to expect an even larger tax increase.
“I went out with an 18% tax increase, a reduction in workforce and we’re still at a $2.5 million loss,” Kiernan said regarding the comprehensive budget. “So if we’re not going to reduce the workforce, then we might have to increase taxes more. I don’t see any other way – unless the council wants to use more fund balance. So I need to prepare options for them, and they can make the decision.”
“We we did look at revenue since the comp budget – we do believe we can increase sales tax and occupancy tax by a couple $100,000 total, the building department does have some big projects, we heard from the supervisors $60,000 from the county – but again, I need to look at all that to determine the increase in revenue, and then we need to look at our expenses…we are at the edge, where we’re doing everything bare minimum as it is, so no matter what we do I don’t see us adding much to the budget. But if we do, my first objective would be to preserve headcount.”
Kirnan also acknowledged that when looking for solutions to the layoffs, she’s not just looking for how to preserve firefighters but also how to preserve the people in City Hall who are potentially at risk of being reduced.
“We have to work with everyone to try to preserve all the headcount. I’ve been trying that from the beginning,” Kirenan said. “The comp budget is a ‘worst-case scenario,’ and so we need to, maybe, lose people through attrition; that would be ideal, but when you put out a comp budget, I needed people to say, ‘this is the worst-case scenario’ and here’s what we’re going to have. It is the fallback.”
During the public comment period, several people spoke regarding the potential firefighter layoffs, including one named Liz, who shared that she has lived in the Spa City for decades, and in recent years, felt like the City Council has not prioritized residents – and laying off firefighters would further prove that to her, urging the council to be the administration that prioritizes Saratogians.
“I’m tired, I’m legit tired,” Liz said. “I feel like the residents of Saratoga Springs really are not a top priority. I feel like it’s the non-residents, the people that have been coming for the summers. I know they’re important to us; they help with our taxes, and they help with all of our businesses and I want our small businesses to thrive…but our people are suffering, and if we get rid of our fire department and members of our fire department, we are going to suffer more. I have elderly parents who need an emergency response frequently, unfortunately.
“But I’m not the only one who’s dealing with that, and I know there are people, many, many people in the city of Saratoga, who also need these responses.”
“I really would love it to see if our administration here and in the future really starts considering the people who physically live here all the time when it comes to all of the things, because I’m really feeling like we are not a top priority.”
A full recording of Tuesday night’s meeting can be found on the city’s website.
© 2026 The Saratogian, Saratoga Springs, N.Y.
Visit www.saratogian.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.