Trending Topics

Poll call: How prevalent are residency requirements?

In a near equal split, 52% of respondents say their department does not have residency restrictions, while 48% say their department does

GettyImages-1292217535.jpg

Photo/Getty Images

News about consideration of a residency requirement for LAFD firefighters sparked hundreds of comments on Facebook. What do you think about the report? Join the conversation.

By Rachel Engel

In November, FireRescue1 reported that the Los Angeles Fire Department is considering adding a residency requirement for firefighters, after a report created for the Board of Fire Commissioners revealed that 115 firefighters with the department live out of state.

“My number one concern is that unexpected, catastrophic event that we have to recall people,” LAFD Chief Ralph Terrazas said in a discussion with fire commissioners.

In a recent FireRescue1 poll, we asked readers, “Does your department have residency restrictions that require members to live within a certain distance of the fire department/assigned station?”

In a near-even split, 52% answered no, their department does not have or enforce residency requirements, while 48% said their department does.

FR1NovPollResultsinarticle.png

Chief Marc Bashoor, executive editor for FireRescue1, weighed in on the topic with a nuanced take: “As a chief, we have responsibilities to our organizational health, which includes the potential for call-back during disaster or crisis scenarios. When firefighters are living three or four states away, the health of the organization suffers, especially during those crisis call-back moments, but also during ‘routine-mandatory’ overtime situations.”

However, he does not see the situation as one-size-fits-all.

“As a ‘firefighter,’ I am somewhat conflicted on residency requirements; that said, I am not in favor of strict jurisdictional requirements – those that require the individual to live within the municipal/city/county boundaries,” he said.

Instead, Bashoor believes a middle-ground approach is the best way to serve the needs community members, individual firefighters and the department: “I am in favor of a residency ‘clause,’ if you will, that provides incentives for response to call-back within, say, one hour, graduated down to four hours. Beyond that, some clause that requires firefighters to live within so many miles or drive-time of the employees’ jurisdiction is generally in the best interest of the jurisdiction AND the employee, in my humble opinion.”

What’s your opinion on residency requirements? Weigh in on the discussion with a comment below.

Rachel Engel is an award-winning journalist and the senior editor of FireRescue1.com and EMS1.com. In addition to her regular editing duties, Engel seeks to tell the heroic, human stories of first responders and the importance of their work. She earned her bachelor’s degree in communications from Cameron University in Lawton, Oklahoma, and began her career as a freelance writer, focusing on government and military issues. Engel joined Lexipol in 2015 and has since reported on issues related to public safety. Engel lives in Wichita, Kansas. She can be reached via email.