Trending Topics

FDIC 2025: Retired FDNY officer, instructor ‘pardoned’ 16 years after ‘Culture of Extinguishment’ speech

FDIC 2025 opened with a bit of tongue-in-cheek humor that included a popular keynote speech from Ray McCormack

INDIANAPOLIS — Similar to a ‘Saturday Night Live’ cold open skit, the FDIC 2025 conference opened with Fire Engineering Editor-in-Chief David Rhodes issuing “executive orders” for the nation’s fire service.

One of those orders involved a “pardon” issued to retired FDNY Lieutenant Ray McCormack following the hype and backlash after his 2009 FDIC keynote speech.

What was the Culture of Fire Extinguishment speech about?

McCormack claimed the fire service needed a “culture of extinguishment not safety” during the 2009 keynote speech.

“Too much safety makes Johnny a poor leader and a terrible rescuer,” McCormack said. “Attempting to make the job safer by teaching you to place yourself above those in need is wrong and goes against everything the fire service has ever stood for.”

Why did Ray McCormack get in trouble for his FDIC speech?

McCormack was in his FDNY uniform when he delivered the keynote speech, which prompted the backlash, according to Bobby Halton, who was editor-in-chief of Fire Engineering at the time.

Following McCormack’s remarks, Salvatore Cassano, who was serving as the FDNY’s chief of department, said the speech “undermined a message we have worked hard to communicate to members of our department — the importance of firefighter safety.”

For his part, Halton said he failed to inform speakers at the conference that if they chose to present in uniform, they had to ensure their speech was consistent with the policies, procedures and positions of their organizations.

“It was for that reason and that reason alone that I chose to take the video down,” Halton said.

Can you still hear Ray McCormack’s FDIC keynote speech?

Despite being removed from Fire Engineering’s site, several YouTube videos of McCormack’s ‘Culture of Extinguishment’ speech still exist. You can watch his remarks below:


Challenging the fire service to adopt language and values that reflect professionalism, preparation and dedication
Trending
Captain David Meyer joined the department in 1996 and was assigned to Truck 29
Dawson County Deputy Jessie Perez had served with the sheriff’s office for eight months; he also served with the O’Donnell Volunteer Fire Department and Lynn County EMS
Detailing the expectations of the job and the three steps to becoming a volunteer firefighter

  1. Fire Captain Joe Hunter and Fire Lieutenant Chrissy Sarnowsky bring their firefighting skills and resilience to the latest season of CBS’s ‘Survivor.’

FireRescue1 Staff is dedicated to providing firefighters with trusted, timely, and actionable information. Our experienced team of writers, editors, and fire service professionals delivers the latest news, expert insights, and training resources to support firefighters in their mission to protect lives and property. From breaking stories to in-depth analysis, FireRescue1 Staff ensures you stay informed and prepared for the challenges of the fire service.

Interested in expert-driven resources delivered for free directly to your inbox? Subscribe for free to any of our newsletters.

You can also connect with us on YouTube, Instagram, X, Facebook, and LinkedIn.