By Chad Drury
Ottumwa Courier
OTTUMWA, Iowa — Though many of the details are still fluid and questions remain to be answered, the Ottumwa Fire Department has made its proposal to the city for staffing levels to operate a fire-based ambulance and address EMS shortages.
Deputy Fire Chief David Cronin and others suggested adding six full-time personnel to run a 24-hour service out of the south side fire station, but that number is dependent on a consistently high call volume.
| MORE: Election day 2026: The votes are in. The EMS challenges haven’t changed.
During a special meeting Tuesday at City Hall, Cronin presented the city council with adding either three, six or nine personnel, with the only figure generating revenue for the city being three additional personnel. However, that would force the department to pull a firefighter off a scene to help run the ambulance, creating a shortage of firefighters at a structure fire, for example.
Adding six would allow fire events to keep adequate personnel on site, but an ambulance service would have to respond to over 1,300 calls a year to break even financially.
“I think you get more bang for your buck if we do the six, and then that will alleviate quite a bit of overtime,” assistant fire chief Josh Chance told the council. “The more overtime we can drop, I mean, we’re already paying for it now with overtime.”
However, the start-up costs could be taxing for a city already facing a shortfall of over $500,000 in its budget. City finance director Michael Lee, who hadn’t yet seen the financial projections, said it would cost over $128,000 apiece for three new personnel, including insurance benefits, a cost that will recur each year. Also, it would cost about $50,000 to equip the ambulance at the south station.
No decisions were made at the meeting as it was simply a presentation from the fire department, but it’s anticipated there will be a financial ask from Wapello County during its Nov. 17 board of supervisors meeting.
Fire department officials were optimistic it would receive enough calls to fund the service, but the discussion left open the question of whether this service would be in coordination or competition with ORMICS, which runs the ambulance service out of Ottumwa Regional Health Center, though that department has seen staffing challenges.
“We don’t intend on doing additional things like interfacility transfers, but [ORMICS] could capture as a primary transport in and out of the town and into the county,” Cronin said. “The conversation that really needs to happen is what is going to be OK for everybody at the end of this.”
Lee also wondered if ORMICS staffs two ambulances and potentially a third, and whether that would cut down on the number of calls the fire department would receive.
However, the city will be on the hook for a lot of the recurring costs as well as increased insurance exposure since ambulances get in accidents more often than other safety vehicles. Other hidden costs include supplies, insurance, fuel and any overtime pay.
City administrator Philip Rath was concerned about the impact on the budget, and what would need to be cut to fund the service.
“This is a big ask for the city to take on, and when we’re already in a shortfall, any additional shortfall that could occur is going to mean trade-offs for other services,” he said.
“One way to adjust for any shortfall would be to consider increasing the franchise fee to cover these costs. That would be one way to make up the revenue side where things fall short.”
© 2026 the Ottumwa Courier (Ottumwa, Iowa).
Visit www.ottumwacourier.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.