Trending Topics

3 former Fla. firefighters avoid jail in waterboarding, hazing plea deal

Three former Marion County firefighters who admitted to attacking a rookie firefighter will serve probation under a plea deal, while charges against a paramedic were dropped

MARION COUNTY, Fla. — Three former Marion County firefighters arrested for waterboarding an employee during a hazing incident took a plea deal.

In court on April 30, the former firefighters admitted to attacking 19-year-old Kayne Stuart. Though a judge seemed hesitant to accept the state’s offer, ultimately the victim, Stuart, was satisfied with the plea agreement, FOX 35 reported.

| EARLIER: ‘That went way too far': Details released in Fla. FD hazing, waterboarding

Kayne Stuart, a 19-year-old rookie firefighter at Marion County Fire Rescue’s Station 21, was assaulted Nov. 16 in what the department described as a hazing incident, according to the Marion County Sheriff’s Office.

Investigators said several firefighters restrained Stuart, beat him with his own belt, dragged him across a parking lot and waterboarded him three times with a towel while trying to get access to his cellphone to view a video he had posted on social media.

Stuart called the attack in an earlier interview as painful and humiliating, adding, “I was literally unable to breathe.”

After an investigation, the four firefighters were fired and charged with battery and false imprisonment.

Kaylee Bradley, a paramedic with the department for two years, was arrested on robbery-related charges, which were later dropped.

Firefighter/EMTs Tate Trauthwein, Edward Kenny and Seth Day were each charged with battery and false imprisonment.

Under the plea deal, Trauthwein, Kenny and Day will each serve one year of probation and avoid prison time.

They also must complete a four-hour bullying awareness class, a 10-hour anger management course and 100 hours of community service.

Some members will simply never have equal power to exercise control over others using the same hazing tactics
Trending
In partnership with Pierce Manufacturing Inc., the International Association of Fire Chiefs announced the 2026 IAFC Fire Chief of the Year honorees at Fire-Rescue International in Kansas City
Learn the full history of firefighter decon, from dirty gear to modern-day protocols that save lives
A judge upheld an arbitrator’s order reinstating the Kansas City firefighter with back pay and a three-day suspension after a pumper crash that killed three people
Proposed legislation following the Boyle Heights warehouse fire would require emergency contingency funds for new cold storage facilities and allow stiffer fines
Company News
The Ricochet PPE Award Program will provide 15 volunteer departments with 75 sets of specialized gear for EMS, wildland and technical rescue operations

Bill Carey is the associate editor for FireRescue1.com and EMS1.com. A former Maryland volunteer firefighter, sergeant, and lieutenant, Bill has written for several fire service publications and platforms. His work on firefighter behavioral health garnered a 2014 Neal Award nomination. His ongoing research and writings about line-of-duty death data is frequently cited in articles, presentations, and trainings. Have a news tip? He can be reached at news@lexipol.com.