Trending Topics

Former CAL FIRE firefighter sues over beard policy, religious accommodation denial

The former firefighter claims he was fired after requesting a religious accommodation for his Orthodox Christian grooming practices, which conflicted with the agency’s facial hair policy tied to respirator mask safety standards

Ohio township board fires fire chief over political activity, insubordination (1).jpg

A CAL FIRE Sonoma-Lake-Napa Unit strike team at a Nevada wildfire in August, 2026.

CAL FIRE Sonoma-Lake-Napa Unit/Facebook

By Colin Atagi
The Press Democrat

SONOMA COUNTY, Calif. — A former Cal Fire firefighter from Sonoma County has filed suit against the agency, saying he faced religious discrimination after he asked for accommodations from an internal facial hair policy that conflicted with his Orthodox Christian grooming practices.

Kynan Barrios filed a complaint Aug. 19 in Sonoma County Superior Court claiming he faced retaliation and was terminated in 2024 after asking CAL FIRE leaders for a religious accommodation.

| WEBINAR: What firefighters want from training

The Rohnert Park man’s claim alleges religious discrimination, failure to reasonably accommodate religious creed, retaliation and failure to prevent discrimination.

Jason Clay, a local CAL FIRE spokesperson, said the agency cannot comment on pending litigation. Barrios’ attorney did not respond to requests for comment.

According to the complaint, Barrios served with CAL FIRE’s Sonoma - Lake - Napa unit during the 2021-2024 fire seasons. Transparency California, a public database on state public employees, shows he was a Firefighter One and his annual pay and benefits were between $71,462 and $98,883.

Barrios made his first accommodation request on April 19, 2024, according to the complaint, and CAL FIRE cited safety and respiratory-protection concerns in rejecting the request.

“Plaintiff alleges that those concerns were not evaluated on an individualized basis and did not account for a successful self-contained breathing apparatus fit test in April 2024 while he had his facial hair,” the complaint states.

CAL FIRE’s hair grooming policy requires facial hair that does not obstruct breathing masks. Among other requirements, mustaches cannot extend below the bottom of the upper lip, nor more than a half-inch beyond the corner of the mouth.

Requirements follow standards by offices including the National Fire Protection Association and Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which emphasize facial hair cannot interfere with the seal of Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus masks.

In part, the NFPA’s entry on facial hair states, “Members who have a beard or facial hair at any point where the facepiece is designed to seal with the face or whose hair could interfere with the operation of the unit shall not be permitted to use respiratory protection at emergency incidents or in hazardous or potentially hazardous atmospheres.”

In his complaint, Barrios contends at least four CAL FIRE firefighters had facial hair that did not meet standards but did not result in discipline.

Five days after making his request in April 2024, according to Barrios’ complaint, he received a written warning over compliance with grooming standards. Five days after that, Barrios said, he submitted a written request for religious accommodation but was denied on May 15, 2024.

A supervisor later reprimanded him, according to the complaint, and threatened discipline and accused Barrios of “tearing apart the crew.”

“(Barrios) disputes that the later warnings, counseling and criticisms were administered neutrally,” the complaint states. “He alleges that disputed incidents and minor workplace issues were documented and escalated more aggressively after he requested accommodation and complained about discriminatory treatment.”

According to Barrios’ complaint, CAL FIRE terminated him Oct. 10, 2024, citing “safety, readiness, performance, interpersonal, insubordination and operational misconduct” as reasons for his dismissal.

In the aftermath, according to Barrios, CAL FIRE issued a bulletin in March 2025 advising personnel to “restrict or escort him” if he appeared on property.

Barrios’ complaint alleges he has suffered emotional distress, anxiety, humiliation, loss of professional standing and disruption to his firefighting career. As of August of this year, he was working as a security guard.

A case management conference is scheduled for Feb. 9 before Sonoma County Judge Dana Simonds.

From hairstyles to visible tattoos, departments are revisiting appearance rules while maintaining operational readiness and professionalism
Trending
The Great Kills intersection of Cloverdale Avenue and Oakdale Street is now “Firefighter Michael W. Daly Way,” honoring a firefighter, youth coach and PTA president who died in 2023
Thousands of incarcerated people fight California wildfires, but few become career firefighters. Programs like the Ventura Training Center aim to change that
Saratoga Springs’ firefighters union rejected a proposal for three-person engine crews as the city weighs layoffs in a budget shortfall
Shanksville Volunteer Fire Department put a new Spartan engine into service and retired the 1993 unit that responded first to the Flight 93 crash

© 2026 The Press Democrat (Santa Rosa, Calif.).
Visit www.pressdemocrat.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Company News
10 departments will each receive a $20,000 grant from AES, in partnership with the National Volunteer Fire Council