Trending Topics

Federal court rejects Wash. firefighters’ COVID-19 vaccination exemption appeal

The appeals court agreed Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue faced undue hardship if it excused the unvaccinated crew members, citing safety, staffing and operational risks during the pandemic

FR1 Affiliate images - 2025-09-04T102742.959.jpg

Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue apparatus.

Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue/Facebook

SAN FRANCISCO — The Ninth Circuit on Tuesday affirmed a lower-court decision favoring Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue, finding that granting COVID-19 vaccine religious exemptions to eight firefighters would have imposed an undue hardship during the pandemic.

After then-Gov. Jay Inslee mandated COVID-19 shots for all healthcare workers in August 2021, Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue imposed the same requirement on its firefighters, but allowed staff to apply for religious accommodations, My Northwest reported.

| READ NEXT: Analyzing the pandemic’s impact on fire and EMS personnel

The department denied the eight plaintiffs’ requests, among 46 filed, saying no feasible accommodation existed.

The court concluded the department had demonstrated that granting the exemptions would create undue hardship, pointing to public and firefighter safety concerns, the high volume of requests, operational risks and the expense of likely staffing shortages.

A union agreement allows affected firefighters to exhaust accrued leave, take up to a year off and keep priority rehire status.

The eight plaintiffs argued this leave policy failed to meet accommodation requirements, but the Ninth Circuit ruled the department’s approach was lawful, noting that any other arrangement would have posed an undue operational burden.

Trending
The gunman drove a flag-bearing pickup into a Grand Blanc Latter-day Saints church, opened fire and started a blaze
How a simple question — “Can you paint our engine pink?” — led to a powerful campaign for firefighters
A falling tree struck the seasonal firefighter on the Tinker Bugs fire in the Nez Perce–Clearwater National Forests
A nickel-cadmium battery mixed into a 60-foot pile ilikely ignited a Springfield blaze, which took 4.5 million gallons of water and six hours to control
Company News
Incident Command
Lightweight, durable, and built for modern crowd control

Bill Carey is the associate editor for FireRescue1.com and EMS1.com. A former Maryland volunteer firefighter, sergeant, and lieutenant, Bill has written for several fire service publications and platforms. His work on firefighter behavioral health garnered a 2014 Neal Award nomination. His ongoing research and writings about line-of-duty death data is frequently cited in articles, presentations, and trainings. Have a news tip? He can be reached at news@lexipol.com.